Continence

Leaking after prostate surgery: sling vs artificial sphincter

Why leakage happens after prostatectomy, what the first year usually looks like, and how a male sling and an artificial urinary sphincter compare.

Written by Dr. Casey McCraw, MD, urologist Last updated Sources cited Editorial policy

7 min readPublished Updated

Leaking urine after a radical prostatectomy is one of the most common reasons men see a reconstructive urologist. It is usually stress incontinence: urine escapes when you cough, stand up, lift or exercise, because the muscle that seals the outlet was close to the prostate and was affected by surgery.

The first year

Continence often improves steadily for months. The AUA/SUFU guideline recommends offering pelvic floor muscle exercises or formal training right after prostatectomy, and again to men seeking treatment for leakage later on.1 A physical therapist who works with men can make sure you are contracting the right muscles.

On timing, the 2024 guideline update says surgery may be offered as early as six months when leakage is not improving despite conservative care, and should be offered at one year to men still bothered by stress leakage.2

Two proven operations

A male sling is a soft strip of mesh placed under the urethra through a small incision behind the scrotum. It supports and repositions the urethra so that it closes better under pressure. There is nothing to operate afterward.

An artificial urinary sphincter is a three-part device: a cuff around the urethra, a pump in the scrotum and a small pressure-regulating balloon. The cuff stays closed. When you want to urinate, you squeeze the pump, the cuff opens for a few minutes and then refills on its own.

The question is rarely which device is better in general. It is which device suits your leakage, your history and your hands.

How they compare

Male slingArtificial sphincter
Guideline fitMild to moderate stress leakageMild to severe stress leakage
Severe leakageNot routinely recommendedAppropriate
After radiationLess favoredPreferred
Daily effortNoneUsing a scrotal pump

Based on the AUA/GURS/SUFU guideline (2024).2

Before either operation, the guideline recommends looking inside the urethra and bladder with a small camera (cystoscopy) to check for scar tissue or other problems that would change the plan.1

Radiation and other options

Radiation changes the tissues around the urethra. Men who have had it should be told that leakage is common after later prostate surgery, and when an operation is chosen, the guideline favors an artificial sphincter over slings or adjustable balloons.2

Bulking injections into the urethra are sometimes suggested as a smaller step. The guideline asks that men be told plainly that their effectiveness is low and cure is rare.2 Pads, penile clamps and condom catheters remain reasonable choices for men who prefer not to have surgery.

Sources

  1. Sandhu JS, Breyer B, Comiter C, Eastham JA, Gomez C, et al. Incontinence after prostate treatment: AUA/SUFU guideline. J Urol. 2019;202(2):369-378. View source
  2. Breyer BN, Kim SK, Kirkby E, Marianes A, Vanni AJ, Westney OL. Updates to incontinence after prostate treatment: AUA/GURS/SUFU guideline (2024). J Urol. 2024;212(4):531-538. View source

This article is general education for adults and isn’t a substitute for a personal examination. In an emergency, call 911.

Keep reading